The Top 20 Records of 2005, According to Me
I have a little theory that I'd like to let you in on: music geekery is a genetic abnormality. And how, you ask, do I purport to support such a lofty claim? The answer is simple: all pop music nerds display similar characteristics, foremost among them being a compulsive need to validate their opinions through the compilation of lists. Well, this is the first year in quite some time that I've found myself not writing for one publication or another at year's end, so I am turning to you, loyal reader, in my time of need. Won't you bolster my sense of self-worth by quickly skimming over the list below and feigning interest? Just think of how much I've given you while asking so little in return. Alternately, feel free to consider this list either a late Christmas present or an early shogatsu gift, your choice.
All albums are classified as 2005 releases based on their US release dates with the exception of the following: Tokumaru Shugo's L.S.T. (which, in all likelihood, will not see an American release) and Regina Spektor's Soviet Kitsch (whose release and re-release history is so confusing, I've simply decided to include it here, rather than shaft a fine record). Considering that I made such a controversial choice for my #1, I probably should have done that thing where the list goes backwards and counts down from 20. Well, there's always next year, I suppose.
1. Bright Eyes - I’m Wide Awake It’s MorningGrowing up is hard enough as it is but poor Conor Oberst did it with the tape running. It’s all there-the melodramatic excess of adolescence, the search for identity (six-strings or synths?), even the awkward squeaks of puberty. While it was precisely these qualities that some (including myself) found intriguing, the very same traits understandably placed Oberst at odds with many serious music fans. It is the latter category to whom I now speak: take note, our little Conor’s all grown-up. I’m Wide Awake It’s Morning is a record of such incredible restraint and focus, it practically dares you not to like it. Oberst wastes no time in knocking out ten straight-up folk-country numbers, already well-worn from years of touring. No smoke and mirrors (or fevers) this time around, just the voice of one of the most promising American songwriters of his generation (there, I said it). It’s true though, Oberst demonstrates that he’s graduated from emo self-awareness into the realm of real songwriting by marrying his bountiful emotion to context. To that end, I’m Wide Awake is a period piece through and through; deftly interweaving the personal and the political into a cohesive portrait of modern life. Plain and simple, this record is more than Oberst’s definitive statement; it’s a legitimate masterpiece of folk-country songwriting.
2. M.I.A. – ArularI was recently at a Kentucky Fried Chicken in Hachinohe when “Galang” came on over the loudspeakers. As I nodded my head in agreement I thought about what a shame it was that I was the only one present who noticed the irony of M.I.A’s bouncy third-world strife juxtaposed with the crunchy taste of cultural imperialism. Even if they could understand the lyrics, would the lunch crowd have realized that the “shotgun” isn’t metaphorical? Did the suits at the corporate office mistake “get down” for an imperative to dance? This is the beauty of Arular, its grimy beats and tinkering electronics brilliantly candy coat what is essentially a politically, socially and sexually subversive record. Who else could flaunt ties to terrorist organizations while simultaneously selling songs to car companies? Arular is just too catchy, danceable and downright fun to ever be spotted for the Trojan horse it really is. Would you like a biscuit with that?
3.Sufjan Stevens - IllinoisDon’t get me wrong: I loved the songs on last year’s Michigan as much as the next guy. But as much as I may have respected that record for the feat of craftsmanship that it is, its massive scope and excessive runtime made actually listening to it seem like a chore. So it was with a fair amount of trepidation that I approached Illinois, an ode to my adopted home state that boasts an even longer runtime and even larger scale. But you know what? This record is just so damn good that I was riveted from the first listen. Taken separately, these 22 tracks run the gamut from sparse intimacy to orchestral sweep, from delicate odes to haunting confessionals. But together they provide a portrait of Midwestern American life that packs more personality than you’ll ever find in any tourist board brochure. Not only has Stevens become a more evocative storyteller, he’s also managed to one-up the musicianship on Michigan; the songs on Illinois explode with the bombast of a marching band yet still manage to feel personal. As far as I’m concerned, the next 48 can’t come soon enough.
4. Andrew Bird - Andrew Bird and the Mysterious Production of EggsIt’s unfortunate but The Mysterious Production of Eggs is precisely the type of record that’s bound to be overlooked come time for year-end lists. It wasn’t accompanied by years of press grooming like Bright Eyes or deafening grassroots hype like M.I.A. Mr. Bird didn’t make the O.C. like Sufjan and Rolling Stone will likely never give him the time of day. But this is just as well for The Mysterious Production of Eggs, a record that’s as understated and quietly unassuming as it is flawless. Armed with a violin, guitar, some bells and his trademark whistle, Bird crafts an album of intelligent folk-pop that easily surpasses all expectations. Catchy, complex, light-hearted and literate, The Mysterious Production of Eggs is the type of record I couldn’t forget even if I tried.
5. Bloc Party – Silent Alarm/Silent Alarm RemixedI guess I should probably hate this band, huh? All trendy outfits and British press hype, their hair carefully disheveled for the video by a team of stylists and their boots freshly polished by the collective tongue of the NME. If only they hadn’t somehow managed to debut with not one but two absolutely perfect records in the space of a year. Silent Alarm is a fucking spotless record, post-punk that’s as clean as it is calculated and all the better for it. These guys operate with the accuracy of surgeons, dropping perfectly timed hooks at every opportunity and trading-off riffs like baseball cards. The record’s real strength, however, lies in its consistency; while the tempos may vary, the catchiness of the tracks does not. And to top it all off, they put out an equally faultless remix record that only proves what we knew all along: Silent Alarm is a totally danceable record. Put on your dancing shoes and grab your metronome, we’re stepping out.
6. Regina Spektor - Soviet KitschWhen it comes to pop music, the breakup record is truly an archetypical form. But I’ve never heard one quite like this before. Like all great breakup records, Soviet Kitsch is permeated by a sense of loss and desperation-but that’s a given. What sets it apart is that Spektor manages to be fun, irreverent and even downright silly without detracting a bit from the record’s heavy thematics. If anything, her flippancy only makes her that much more convincing. If I told you that the most depressing song I heard all year opened with the lines “I had a dream/crispy, crispy Benjamin Franklin came over/and babysat all four of my kids” would you believe me?
7. Patrick Wolf – The Wind in the WiresShockingly young, broodingly photogenic and surprisingly prolific with a flair for mixing electronics with traditional folk instrumentation-but wait, isn’t Conor Oberst already on this list? All joking aside, this Wolf is a different animal altogether (okay, maybe not all joking); he’s clearly far more skilled in composition than Oberst and is equally adept at stirring up theatrics whether armed with a mandolin or a sequencer. And then there’s his voice, rich beyond his 21 years and reminiscent of the best crooners of 80s British pop. The Wind in the Wires is a huge step forward from the hodgepodge that was last year’s Lycanthropy, proving that Wolf is more than capable of a statement that’s unified both musically and thematically.
8. Kanye West - Late RegistrationHow do you follow up something like last year’s breakthrough hit The College Dropout? Kanye cooked up an answer: producing a record with Jon Brion that showcases more varied production and instrumentation alongside the camera-ready persona we know and love. That’s right, Kanye’s back with all his contradictions in tow-is he going to jock the plight of mine workers in Sierra Leone while flossing those diamonds? You’d better believe it. Is he really going to feature Nas and a member of Maroon 5 on the same record? Of course. And is he gonna ride to the top of the charts in a sweater vest and designer sunglasses? Just try and stop him. Sure, Late Registration looks unfocused next to Dropout and falls far short of delivering last year’s unstoppable string of singles. But consider the flip side: it’s a much more consistent affair, inviting the listener to curb the urge to skip straight to the jams. Above all, Kanye’s success continues to breathe more creativity and innovation into mainstream hip-pop than anyone else in recent memory. He may be a dropout but he’s deftly made it past the sophomore slump.
9. Annie – AnniemalIndie music nerds have long had a mercurial relationship with so called “Pop” music. While we’ve spent years investing in hybrid terms like “electro-pop” and “indie-pop” in order to distance ourselves from the Billboard chart, we’re all too happy to worship at the alter of chart-toppers from decades past. And now, all of a sudden, hipsters are embracing even contemporary mainstream pop, if only to prove that they’re not as elitist as all that. So it appears that Annie has arrived right on time; as infectious as anything on the radio and twice as complex, Anniemal proves that sugary-sweet bubblegum and innovation aren’t such strange bedfellows after all. While this record may not be the postmodern savior that will bridge the gap between the dance floor and the record store, it’s certainly a step in that direction. When I played Anniemal for my friend Ryan, he remarked that he was already sick of it from hearing “Chewing Gum” being played non-stop at every club in Finland. We should all be so lucky.
10. Okkervil River - Black Sheep BoyA few years ago, Okkervil River were well on track to joining the ranks of competent alt-country bands. But somewhere along the way, two roads diverged and the River emerged from the yellow wood a Black Sheep Boy. While sometimes reminiscent of In the Aeroplane Over the Sea’s character-based song cycle as concept aesthetic, Black Sheep Boy finds the Austin five-piece exhibiting a style uniquely their own. Somewhere between the rollicking guitars, bleating organs and Will Sheff’s yelps is a series of lovingly crafted, allegorical tales. It’s finding them that’s all the fun.
11. Common – BeChicago MC Common had some lean years there but who knew he had a comeback like this in him? Credit is due to Kanye, for reinvigorating the respected MC after 2002’s disastrous Electric Circus with tracks that allow Common Sense’s inimitable flow to shine. Lead single “The Corner” is a strong contender for hip-hop single of the year, extracting so much energy out of a chopped-up vocal sample that it bounces off of alley walls as Common cruises the streets of Chicago, building a lyrical shrine to street culture. Between Kanye, Common and the Sox, 2005 may well have been the year that the south side finally got to shine.
12. Antony and the Johnsons – I Am A Bird NowI’m going to have to ask all of you to suspend your cynicism for just a minute. Of course, you could send I Am A Bird Now off for analysis, in order to determine the precise ratio of style to substance. Sure, you could point out that the ghosts of the New York cabaret scene and the specter of AIDS take up more space in the press than 6-foot tall Antony himself. But you would be completely missing the point. Just listen to the damn thing. What do you hear? A record of genuine sadness, graceful desperation and above all, beauty. And he wraps it all up in that voice of his: the only instrument rich and deep enough to give these songs their due.
13. The Decemberists – PicaresqueHi, is this the Decemberists? Hey, I’m really glad I was able to inexplicably get all of you on the phone simultaneously like this. Now, as you know, we’ve had our differences in the past. Maybe it was the annoyingly enthusiastic fan base? Or the over the top, theatrical shtick? You know, it was probably just the constant critical comparisons to the likes of Neutral Milk Hotel. At any rate, I was pretty determined to hate you guys regardless of your musical output. I even went as far as to leave Intonation early so I wouldn’t have to see you. Well, the reason I’m calling today is to say that I just can’t keep up the façade anymore. I accidentally ended up listening to Picaresque this year and it was just too damn good to hate. Eleven self-encapsulated narratives that somehow come together to form a thematic whole? I know, how could I resist, right? And those call and response vocals from beyond the grave on “The Mariner’s Revenge Song”? Yeah, that shit was tight! Well, before I go, I really need to ask you guys a favor. Now that you’ve signed with Capitol and all, do you think you could make a really crappy record? Yeah, I just don’t want to risk having to like you guys at the expense of being cool. Thanks, I knew you’d understand. Take it easy, guys.
14. Spoon – Gimme FictionDo you remember that kid in college who acted like he was all laid-back and didn’t really care about school but somehow managed to squeeze onto the dean’s list every year? Yeah, I hated that guy too. But I can’t hate Spoon because I’m beginning to suspect that it’s not an act. They just keep getting better and better while maintaining their characteristic cool. Making records this tight can’t really be effortless-can it? Whether aping Prince on the deliciously funky “I Turn my Camera On” or greeting earnestness with a smirk on “I Summon You,” they really do make it seem that way. Not that I care, or anything.
15. The Fiery Furnaces – EPIf the laws of theoretical physics hold true, there is an alternate dimension out there somewhere where rock albums are evaluated solely based on their narrative ability. In this dimension, Colin Meloy is a multi-millionaire, Jeff Mangum is a household name and the Furnaces’ Rehearsing My Choir Tops every critic’s year-end list. But let’s get back to reality. What possibly could have possessed the authors of last year’s best record to birth a musical beast like Choir? In the spirit of the Furnaces, I’ve decided to present my theory to you in the form of a short one-act:
Setting: the critical playground
Bully #1: Hey, Friedbergers! That was a nice concept record you two put out last year! What are you gonna do next, make a record with your Grandma? Huh?
*A light bulb illuminates above Eleanor’s head as Matt is unsuspectingly pantsed from behind*
Choir was a huge risk, so it’s a good thing that they had a solid insurance policy in the form of January’s single-compiling, inaccurately named EP. In 10 tracks of robot Broadway bliss, they answer the question that was on everyone’s lips last year: what would happen if these jokers actually sat down and wrote pop songs? The Fiery Furnaces may have spent the rest 2005 butchering the Beatles and penning the year’s most difficult record but you’ve got to respect their determination to keep pushing the envelope.
16. Fiona Apple - Extraordinary Machine (Jon Brion Version)Fiona Apple is not your average pop songstress. Unlike so many of her contemporaries, she’s passionate, earnest and creative in all of the best ways. Which is why it’s a blessing that these songs found their way to Jon Brion. As he demonstrated just as ably on Late Registration, his strength lies in his ability to expand an artist’s breadth without compromising their vision. The result is that Fiona gets room to breathe, producing songs like the almost spoken-word title track; weird, expansive and delightful. This year’s best record that never was.
17. Wolf Parade – Apologies to the Queen MaryI know, don’t believe the hype, right? But with such an incredible series of self-released EPs, very few were able to resist buying into the myth of Wolf Parade as the next big thing. So how was it that Apologies to the Queen Mary became one of the most divisive records of the year? If you ask me, Issac Brock took a band whose appeal was in their rough edges and cleaned up and polished them until there was no appeal left. I know I’m not the only one who refused to listen to this record for weeks out of sheer disappointment. But eventually, it started creeping it’s way into my playlist. And you know what? These songs are just too good to be ruined by any production. Eventually I came to realize that even if there was something exciting about the immediacy of the EPs, many of these songs deserve to be fully realized like they are on Queen Mary. I’m hedging my bets that this won’t be the definitive statement from Wolf Parade. But until then, it’s a damn fine placeholder.
18. Silver Jews – Tanglewood NumbersDavid Berman hit rock bottom and he’s not trying to hide it. Case in point: he opens up Tanglewood Numbers by asking “Where’s the paper bag that holds the liquor/just in case I feel the need to puke”. Still, there’s redemption to be found here as well, whether in Berman’s oddball humor or in the dialogue with his wife (and songwriting partner) Cassie. Rounding out the package is some terrific musicianship, including that of Stephen Malkmus, whose fretwork gives Berman’s alt-country leanings a real shot in the arm (notice my restraint in not making the obvious, distasteful joke). The result is the liveliest and fullest-sounding arrangements of the Jews' career, overlaid with Berman's most personal songs yet.
19. M. Ward - Transistor RadioMatt Ward has always struck me as a shy fellow. Baseball cap pulled low over his eyes, he’s always made the kind of records that seem to intentionally draw attention away from his incredible finger-style skill. So it’s nice to see him finally coming out of his shell. After showing off his chops with an instrumental cover of the Beach Boys’ “You Still Believe in Me,” Ward opens the record proper with the mission statement “One Life Away”. Trapped under a sea of transistor fuzz, Ward and My Morning Jacket’s Jim James beckon the listener to join them on a journey to a bygone era where fräulein is still a term of endearment and families crowd around the radio. The concept holds up surprisingly well, if only because Ward’s songs have a way of sounding genuinely timeless. It may be one of the best records of 2005 but it sure as hell doesn’t sound like it.
20. Broken Social Scene – S/TThe densest naturally occurring substance on earth is iridium, with a density of roughly 22650 kg per cubic meter. While I may not have the means to actually measure the sonic density of Broken Social Scene, I’m willing to bet that it’s in the same neighborhood. While 2002’s You Forgot It In People sounded surprisingly lean and tight for being produced by such a large collective, Broken Social Scene makes this band sound even larger than it really is, which is a feat in itself. The real hero of this record may well be David Newfeld, whose production teeters precariously on the edge of chaos without ever falling in. In the grand tradition of the obsessed-over studio masterpiece, Broken Social Scene proves that sometimes, more is indeed better.
The Next Ten:
21. Broadcast – Tender Buttons
22. Richard Swift – The Novelist/Walking Without Effort
23. The Mountain Goats – The Sunset Tree
24. Tokumaru Shugo – L.S.T.
25. Jens Lekman – Oh, You’re So Silent Jens
26. Sigur Ros - Takk
27. Yann Tiersen and Shannon Wright - S/T
28. Ryan Adams and the Cardinals – Cold Roses
29. Iron and Wine – Woman King EP
30. Meneguar – I Was Born At Night
Well folks, that's all she wrote. I'm going on vacation as of tomorrow, so don't expect any updates until sometime in mid-January. Until then, have a safe and happy new year's and all of that. See you next year.


























































